Reviewing team assessments

Reviewing team assessments

Use this when you are a reviewer or manager and need to review an employee's assessment: find the reviews waiting on you, read the self-assessment, answer the manager questions, submit with Complete, or send an assessment back. It also covers the cycle's list, heat map and response views and the export, for managers and HR checking how a cycle is going.

Where: Performance › Team performance › Assessments

You need:

  • The Reviewer right, and to be named as a reviewer in the cycle, to review
  • The Admin right to see every cycle and every review under All Reviews

How to find the reviews waiting on you

  1. Go to Performance › Team performance › Assessments. Open cycles are listed first, then Closed ones.
  2. Admins: choose My Reviews to see only the cycles you review, or All Reviews for every cycle.
  3. Select Filters to show All, Open or Closed cycles, or cycles that overlap a date range.
  4. Select a cycle. The header shows Pending My Review: how many employees have submitted and are waiting for your review.
  5. Select Filters, then Pending Manager, to list the employees waiting for a review.

How to review an employee

  1. In the cycle's list, select the employee's row.
  2. Read the Self-Assessment tab: the employee's answers, their comments and their Employee score.
  3. Open the Manager Assessment tab.
  4. Choose an answer for each question. On a Multiple Choice question you can tick several.
  5. Add a Comment to any question. The cycle can require a comment on some questions.
  6. Write your Manager comments to the employee. It is required when the cycle asks for a manager comment.
  7. Select Save to keep a draft, or Complete to submit.

Save and Complete only appear while the assessment is Pending Manager and you have not submitted yet. They are greyed out once the cycle is Closed.

⚠️ Complete is final for you. A submitted review cannot be edited. To change it, an admin has to return the assessment to the reviewer.

How to return an assessment

  1. Open the employee's review.
  2. Select Return to Employee or Return to Reviewer.
  3. Enter a Reason. The person it goes back to sees it in their email.
  4. Select Return.
ButtonWho sees itWhat happens
Return to EmployeeA reviewer who has not submitted yet, while the assessment is Pending ManagerThe self-assessment reopens for the employee, answers kept. Reviews already submitted reopen too, with answers kept, so they can be redone against the new answers. The employee is emailed the reason.
Return to ReviewerAdmins, once the assessment is CompletedEvery reviewer's review reopens, answers kept, and each is emailed the reason.

Returning needs an open cycle, and a self-assessment to return to for Return to Employee.

How to export a cycle

  1. On the cycle's list view, set any search or filters you want.
  2. Select Export.

The Excel file has each employee's Name, Status, Reviewer Name, Employee Score, Reviewer Score, Overall Rating, Employee Comment and Reviewer Comment. A reviewer's export shows only their own reviews.

What the screens show

Team Assessments list

ColumnWhat it shows
Cycle NameThe cycle, its start and due dates, and Overdue if anyone is late.
StatusOpen or Closed.
CompletionSubmitted out of the total. All Reviews: assessments fully completed. My Reviews: reviews you have completed.
Avg ScoresAverage Self and Manager scores out of 5.
… menuEdit, Clone, Save as Recurring, Refresh assignments and Import, for people who can manage the cycle.

The cycle header

ItemWhat it shows
Pending Employee ReviewEmployees who have not submitted their self-assessment.
Pending My ReviewEmployees who have submitted and are waiting for your review.
Review StatusThe share of employees at Employee, Manager and Completed.
View selectorList view, Heat map or Response.

List view columns are Employee, Emp. Score, Mgr Score, Rank, Review Status and Reviewer. Filter by status, department, branch or position, and search by name. See How assessment scores are calculated for what each score means.

Heat map plots each employee's initials by manager score (across, 1 to 5) and self score (up, 1 to 5). Hover over a dot for both scores. The Assessment Ranking list beside it orders everyone by the average of the two, as a percentage. Use it to spot people who rate themselves much higher or lower than their reviewer does.

Response shows, for each question in Self-Assessments and Manager-Assessments, how many people chose each answer and its share, plus an average where the top answer counts highest. Each section also shows the average score, how many have submitted, how many are pending and the number of questions. The filters apply here too.

Statuses

StatusMeans
Pending EmployeeThe employee has not submitted. Reviewers cannot complete yet.
Pending ManagerThe employee has submitted, or the cycle has no self-assessment, and at least one reviewer has not.
CompletedEveryone has submitted.

With several reviewers, the assessment stays Pending Manager until the last one completes. Each reviewer sees only their own review, and admins can switch between reviewers' reviews.

What Happens Next

  • When you select Complete, your score is calculated and shown at once.
  • The employee is told your review is in only if the cycle has Employees Can See Their Reviewer on. Otherwise they never see your answers or score.
  • Each completed assessment goes into the cycle's watchers' next daily email.

Tips

  • Read the self-assessment before you answer. A review that ignores what the employee said reads as if nobody looked.
  • Agree what each answer means with the other reviewers before you start. One generous reviewer moves a whole team's scores.
  • Write comments for the employee. If the cycle shows them your review, they will read every word.
  • Return rather than work around. If the self-assessment is wrong or incomplete, return it with a clear reason before you complete your own review.
  • Use the heat map before calibration meetings. Large gaps between self and manager scores are the conversations worth having.

Troubleshooting / FAQ

Q: I can't see Save or Complete. The employee has not submitted yet, you have already submitted, the cycle is closed, or you are not a reviewer for this employee.

Q: I can't see the employee's self-assessment. The cycle has Reviewer Can See Employee Responses off, or has no self-assessment.

Q: "Can not leave any comments in blank when submitting." A question marked Comment required, or the overall manager comment, is empty.

Q: I submitted, but the status is still Pending Manager. Another reviewer has not submitted. Your own review shows as submitted.

Q: I need to change a review I completed. Ask an admin to use Return to Reviewer, then complete it again.

Q: Return to Reviewer fails with "Invalid status change or no permission to change status." The cycle has no manager assessment, so there is no review to reopen.

Related articles